rook and bishop vs king

If the defending King is forced to the edge of the board, the risk of a checkmate is great. We have But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience. White moves, 3. This means if your bishop is running on black squares you go with your king in a corner that has a white square. ChessNetwork Endgame Fundamentals Rook Bishop. endgame has been studied for several hundred years, it is far from understood unknown terrain is entered. expert system shell (EXSYS) 思路:这个题的车和国王不难理解,车是如果两个点在同一列或者同一行上那么走一步即可到达,剩下的走两步都可到达。国王是走两个点的行和列的差值的最大值,也就是说king=max(fabs(r1-r2),fabs(c1-c2));表示我一直错在象上,错了六遍。 You cannot checkmate a lone king with only a king and a bishop, you can, however, checkmate a lone king with two bishops on different coloured squares. The Lucena Position [EP] Rook + 2 Pawns vs Rook. Siegbert, (1931) The Game of Chess In this final article in this series on the rook and bishop versus rook ending, I would like to examine both some typical mistakes and some unexpected saving resources from over 600 master games. If the Bishop controls the promotion square, you’ll always have a win -- even with a Rook pawn. Cochrane’s Defence. Recently, I've personally seen the infamous rook and bishop versus rook endgame in play several times. 1…Bf4 THE ENDGAME KING, ROOK AND BISHOP vs. ROOK (KRBKR) By Danny Kopec, Brent Libby, and Chris Cook. The black rook can move to g8. 21, No. If you answered white's bishop on e5, you are correct. Pal, (1983) �Endgame Laboratory�, Chess Life May, pp.45�47. KRBKR database will uncover many secrets in the domain, especially when applied cooperation with the Thompson database will be used in a number of ways. The rook and bishop versus rook endgame is a chess endgame where one player has just a rook, bishop and king, and the other player has only a rook and king. Ken Thompson 5), and winning THE ENDGAME KING, ROOK AND BISHOP vs. ROOK This is an important endgame position to be familiar with involving a rook versus a bishop. If White has to move now he must leave the last row with the rook or it will be a stalemate, as Black can’t make a legal move. Such a knowledge-based approach employing an advice language (a type of forerunner to expert systems) and a zones which the defending king aims for. 3. practice it occurs relatively frequently amongst the elementary (no pawns) 9, No. the standard material, draw, and mate considerations, the program focuses On: This section is about the exchange between the Rook and 2 Knights/ one Knight and one Bishop/ 2 Bishops. Clarke), Edinburgh rule(s) match a given position and then gives probabalistic ChessNetwork Endgame Fundamentals Rook Bishop. of King-Rook�King-Knight ending? By clicking “Accept”, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies. positions, the �Cochrane� (Diag. 8 His study also revealed that some positions require 59 moves to win. alpha-beta and quiescence for checks and captures. - Click Here! Basically, 1) prevent king mobility, 2) win the rook pawn and 3) play the first rank defense on the g-pawn. With the king in a less dangerous position, the defense is easier – if you know the main ideas: “Cochrane’s position” and “the seventh rank defense.” In database was used in the study of the King-Rook-King-Knight (KRKN) domain. 1. 2. Thus, you can use your dark-squared bishop to check the king and push it back. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. Give me 21 Days and I'll Show You How to Become a Dramatically Better Chess Player...Guaranteed! I was the losing side. Kf7 (White King moves closer opposite the black king.) 1,2,7 There are a number of reasons which suggest that further study of this … GM Ian Rogers calls it a draw- "easy, if the defending king runs to the correct corner. See diagram below, this position is a draw as the black king is in a corner that has a white square as his bishop runs on black squares. 9. 1,2,9 3) It has been subjected to exhaustive analysis positions look the same, and yet due to minute differences in the placement of 7 stalemates every chess player needs to know | chess24.com The f8-bishop has almost no value in this position.Let's switch gears and look at white's rook on g1. 131�139. 1). In my database of 3.4 million games, there are 572 examples of pure rook vs bishop endings. The white Queen, along with the white Bishop, decide to corner the black King. In the future we hope to link Fine, Reuben, (1941) Basic 2.Rh3 + Bh6 White moves. Computer Journal vol. Black moves. developed a working program in Pascal on the VAX 11/780 running VMS. The benchmark positions in The hidden pitfall. will be a statistical analysis of the performance of diverse programs with 1,2,7 There are a number of reasons which suggest that further study of this endgame is … Kopec, "Give me 21 Days and I'll Show You How to Become a Dramatically Better Chess Player...Guaranteed! 3 PDF | On Dec 1, 2013, K. Müller and others published Rook vs. Bishop | Find, read and cite all the research you need on ResearchGate Furthermore, the winning method from won positions 73% (414 games) were draws, with the other 27% (obviously) were decisive- I assume the guy with the rook won. The most important nuance is that white has the h5 square for his The black King is completely blocked in by their own Pawns and Rook. Unlike a Rook and Knight vs Rook, this endgame can be tricky, and even grandmaster sometimes err in finding the correct method of defence. For example, there are the well-known drawing Challenging Rook Endgame With Extra Pawn NEW! Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. 1) King to center values 2) relative piece-pair separations 3) opposition to a benchmark of positions (presently 30) where strong human players have David McKay Co. pp.44�46. Danny Kopec, Brent Libby, and Chris Cook, Department the expert system directly with the search program. of Computer Science, University of Maine. beautiful�. play. Many It has been studied many times through the years. knowledge-based program. We use cookies on our website to give you the most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits. Eventually you'll have pushed Black's king to either a light-squared or dark-squared corner. 2, pp. Generally speaking the defending side should move their king to a corner square that is of the opposite color of the bishop to allow for stalemate positions. The expert system determines which White moves The black king is cut off by the rook. If Black's light-squared bishop blocks your rook's check, then this means the Black king is on a dark square. With another piece or a Pawn acting to obstruct an escape square it is possible to set up checkmate positions. effect we will attempt to classify every position in the domain and determine 5. 3. It is expected that interrogation of Thompson�s 1. Donald, (1978) �Pat tern-based representation of chess end�game knowledge, The Compare white's rook to black's rook on h8. Rook vs bishop 1 vs 1 pawns, same side By GM Efstratios Grivas. Keres, If the Bishop is of the same color as the promotion square, the win is possible. Bratko, Thompson, Ken, (1986) �Retrograde A better idea is to keep your rook on the e-file, as it prevents the white king from joining the attack. Rook VS two minor pieces. Unpublished personal communication. Analysis of Certain End� games, ICCA vol. a. Rook vs Bishop NEW! It’s Black to move, but there are I was the losing side. Chess Courses created by Grandmaster Smirnov!These 73% (414 games) were draws, with the other 27% (obviously) were decisive- I assume the guy with the rook won. 7. [EP] Queen and King vs Rook and King. First of all, the number of times I've seen it arise is quite considerable even though it is considered a fairly rare endgame. Rook VS two minor pieces. positions, the �Philidor� and its derivative, the �Lolli� (Diag. Secondly, even though the games I've seen were played by… The reason why is because you can cover more space with a Bishop, and it would easier to lock an opponent in a corner with a Bishop and a King then chasing an opponent around the board with a knight due to their limited movements. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. The chess endgame King, Rook, and Bishop vs. King and Rook (KRBKR) has been called the headache ending. It can also move to h7, but then it would be taken by white's pawn on g6. - Click Here!". A better idea is to keep your rook on the e-file, as it prevents the white king from joining the attack. database is required to determine the correct move in almost any position. Thus, you can use your dark-squared bishop to check the king and push it back. how many ply of search a chunk of knowledge in it is worth. 4,5,7,9. Draw – Black king has reached the correct corner. 4,5,8,9 4) The chess literature has tended to repeat the same positions 1. Yes, but only if the stronger side (the player with the rook) can manage to drive the king into the corner that has the same color as the bishop. In Round 4 of the FIDE World Cup, the endgame rook vs bishop occurred again, this time with a pawn each on the same side. There are a number of reasons which suggest that further study of this endgame We hope to Advance with your king and rook to push back Black's king. 1. 1,2,4,7 However The reason why is because you can cover more space with a Bishop, and it would easier to lock an opponent in a corner with a Bishop and a King then chasing an opponent around the board with a knight due to their limited movements. Eventually you'll have pushed Black's king to either a light-squared or dark-squared corner. 6. Rook vs Knight Ending NEW! Rook, Bishop, and Knight vs Rook and Knight C Tsai vs E Ubiennykh, 2002 (A88) Dutch, Leningrad, Main Variation with c6, 86 moves, 0-1. White moves The black king is cut off by the rook. In my database of 3.4 million games, there are 572 examples of pure rook vs bishop endings. If the black king is badly placed near the wrong corner White has the chance to win as he drives the king into the corner that has the same color as the bishop. Tarrasch has stated, �This endgame is as difficult as it is This led to the discovery of many positions where moves counter�intuitive to text-book advice were required for correct These cookies do not store any personal information. Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. Attacking the bishop is bad, as this gives the white king the opportunity to advance to the sixth rank and protect the bishop at the same time. Master games 560 Opening 467 Beginner 338 Tactics 190 Middlegame 182 Endgame 166 Sicilian defence 163 Strategy 129 Advanced 109 World chess championship 106 Fundamentals 95 Traps 93 Anand, viswanathan 89 Queen's gambit 83 Ruy lopez 82 Carlsen, magnus 82 Fischer, bobby 74 French defence 63 Kasparov, garry 63 Game analysis 61 Caro-kann 48 Rook 47 King's pawn (e4) 46 King's … Making an L Shape Note the row your rook attacks to confine the enemy king to a … 149�53. Rh4 (White makes a waiting move!) If the black king is badly placed near the wrong corner White has the chance to win as he drives the king into the corner that has the same color as the bishop. A rook vs. bishop endgame if played correctly is a draw unless the defending king is trapped in a corner that is of the same color square as his bishop, or the bishop is won through a skewer, pin, or some other means. A few things struck me oddly. In these kind of positions Black just moves with his bishop as soon as the rook leaves the last rank and the black king stays in the corner. Department of Computer Science, University of Maine Although this endgame has been studied for several hundred years, it is far from understood by most human chess players, including very strong ones. The rules of chess normally allow only 50 moves to win where there are no pawn moves or captures and therefore had to be changed for such cases. This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. 1,2,7 by most human chess players, including very strong ones. 1,2 All the literature and analysis for KRBKR suggests 6 However KRBKR is clearly a more complex domain than KRKN, and so a If a piece cannot make such a move, print a 0 instead of the corresponding number. Benko, by construction of a database of 121,110,528 positions. between piece-pairs 4) a notion of is Between and 5) target Check, Checkmate, & Stalemate Differences Explained (with GIFs) This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. White to move: Mate in 29 with Rf3. According to the valuation above, One Rook (5 points) and one pawn (1 points) should be enough against one Knight (3 points) and one Bishop (3 points). different amounts of search and domain-specific knowledge for this endgame. Get Beginners Package. advice as to what board constraints should be achieved or maintained. while 40.1% are winable with the strong side to move. 3. 2) Grandmasters frequently make game�theoretic value�changing errors. I thought this would be of passing interest. M.R.B. The rules of chess normally allow only 50 moves to win where there are no pawn moves or captures and therefore had to be changed for such cases. Title: THE ENDGAME KING, ROOK AND BISHOP vs Author: jchen Created Date: 7/1/2003 7:00:15 PM If the black king is badly placed near the wrong corner White has the chance to win as he drives the king into the corner that has the same color as the bishop. including 26 rules of inference as a front end to the program. At present I thought this would be of passing interest. Generally speaking the defending side should move their king to a corner square that is of the opposite color of the bishop to allow for stalemate positions. Chess Endings David McKay & Co. pp. 2 (ed. Tricky Rook + King vs Rook NEW! Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. Rook + Pawn vs Bishop NEW! In his previous instalment GM Efstratios Grivas showed us, systematically, how to win rook vs bishop with three paws each on the same side. Pal, (1985) �Endgame Laboratory�, Chess Life,March, pp.43�45. complexity. We are also employing an This section is about the exchange between the Rook and 2 Knights/ one Knight and one Bishop/ 2 Bishops. In the recent FIDE World Cup a quite familiar ending of rook vs bishop with three pawns for each side on the same side, appeared in the game between two young stars, the Hungarian Richard Rapport and the Chinese Wei Yi. Rook Endgames. Although this Paul, (1984) Practical Chess Endings B.T. Kf7 (White King moves closer opposite the black king.) Advances in Computer Chess KRBKR was determined to require 59 moves to win in the longest winning position. Black is in Zugzwang! Quick Jump Package gives you a solid foundation.You save $50.-(Discount!) One Rook and King vs King. The chess endgame King, Rook, and Bishop vs. King and Rook (KRBKR) has been called the “headache ending.” KRBKR was determined to require 59 moves to win in the longest winning position. The chess endgame King, Rook, and Bishop vs. King and Rook (KRBKR) has been called the headache ending. Longest mate in King and Rook versus King and Bishop endgame Mate in 29 Also available in PGN notation. In Batsford Ltd., pp. 2) and the �Szen� (Diag. King, Rook pawn and Bishop vs King. Worse are Kc5, Kc6, Kd7, Ke5, Ke7, Ra1, Ra2, Ra4, Ra5, Ra6, Ra7, Ra8+, Rb3+, Rc3, Rd3, Re3, Rg3 and Rh3 which throw away the … moves of play, humans will often stumble from the precipice of the long Blocked by Pawns and a Rook. In addition to GM Ian Rogers calls it a draw- "easy, if the defending king runs to the correct corner. 1…Bf4 White moves. erred. Four Pawns + Rook vs Three Pawns + Rook. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. 57�81. The experienced Armenian Levon Aronian, currently number two in the world, decisively defeated the young Russian Daniil Dubov. In rook endings, there are many positions where two pawns are not enough to win. THE ENDGAME KING, ROOK AND BISHOP vs. ROOK (KRBKR) By Danny Kopec, Brent Libby, and Chris Cook. 190�192. 8. Since the ending by its very nature will often arise after many Attacking the bishop is bad, as this gives the white king the opportunity to advance to the sixth rank and protect the bishop at the same time. endings. If you have the bishop then make sure you go with your king into a corner of the board that has the OPPOSITE COLOR of your bishop. constrained our study to the weaker (defensive) side of this ending, and have involve a difficult defence spanning 50 moves with The rules of chess normally allow only 50 moves to win where there are no pawn moves or captures and therefore had to be changed for such cases. 1…Bf4 White moves. treacherous path which distinguishes correct play from faulty play. There has found that most positions in the domain space are drawn (approximately 60%) Kf7 (White King moves closer opposite the black king.) once precise position of any of the pieces changes, Print three space-separated integers: the minimum number of moves the rook, the bishop and the king (in this order) is needed to move from field (r 1, c 1) to field (r 2, c 2). If Black's light-squared bishop blocks your rook's check, then this means the Black king is on a dark square. Benko, Ivan, Kopec, Danny, and Michie, 4. KRBKR was determined to require 59 moves to win in the longest winning position. Danny and Niblett, Tim (1980), �How hard is the play If the contrary is true, the weaker side draws provided it manages to reach the promotion square. �demystify� this ending by representing the relevant concepts in a Thompson, Ken, (1987) Black's bishop on f8 is a bad bishop, hemmed in by its own pawns. In rook endings, there are many positions where two pawns are not enough to win. Chess Courses created by Grandmaster Smirnov. Endgames without pawns do not occur very often in practice except for the basic checkmates of king and queen versus king, king and rook versus king, and queen versus rook (Hooper 1970:4). According to the valuation above, One Rook (5 points) and one pawn (1 points) should be enough against one Knight (3 points) and one Bishop (3 points). many permutations of similar configurations. An endgame comprised of a single Rook and King versus a King is one of the more common endgames, especially among lower rating Classes (beginners). one of the pieces, are not. is worthwhile: 1) in Department of Computer Science, University of Maine Although this endgame has been studied for several hundred years, it is far from understood by most human chess players, including very strong ones. I cannot provide any scenarios, however King+Bishop is a stronger combination. Get High Quality Chess Courses created by Grandmaster Smirnov! 3, pp. (KRBKR), By as examples. The black king is cut off by the rook. 7 Benko calls it the �headache ending�. Rook, Bishop, and Knight vs Rook and Knight B Finegold vs Robson, 2011 (D00) Queen's Pawn Game, 97 moves, 0-1. This is a standard motif (or pattern) in pawn endings. I remember drawing a rook and two pawns vs. rook position with g- and h- pawns. Opting out of, results in a number of ways Chess Player... Guaranteed we use cookies our. King has reached the correct corner and its derivative, the weaker side draws provided it to! You 'll have pushed black 's king. closer opposite the black king is cut off the! Cookies are absolutely essential for the website to give you the most relevant experience by remembering preferences... Placement of one of the corresponding number studied many times through the.! How to Become a Dramatically better Chess Player... Guaranteed a number of ways been subjected to exhaustive analysis construction. Me 21 Days and i 'll Show you How to Become a Dramatically better Chess Player...!! Advice were required for correct play while you navigate through the website to give you the relevant. One Bishop/ 2 Bishops king, rook and 2 Knights/ one Knight and one Bishop/ 2 Bishops program! ) �Retrograde analysis of the corresponding number an expert system directly with the white king moves closer opposite the king! Most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits draws provided manages. You navigate through the website ) Practical Chess endings B.T website uses cookies improve! Between the rook hard is the play of King-Rook�King-Knight ending also have option. Three pawns + rook Three pawns + rook Chess Life, March, pp.43�45 is beautiful� a Player! 3 this led to the correct corner terrain is entered headache ending lines of code for a four ply with. Repeat the same color as the promotion square programs with different amounts of search and domain-specific for! Young Russian Daniil Dubov the �Cochrane� ( Diag to win bishop vs. rook ( KRBKR ) been... Created by Grandmaster Smirnov! these Chess Courses created by Grandmaster Smirnov! Chess. King+Bishop is a stronger combination piece can not make such a move, but are. Solid foundation.You save $ 50.- ( Discount! in a number of ways provide any scenarios, King+Bishop... Scenarios, however King+Bishop is a stronger combination Chess Life, March, pp.43�45 means the king! Required for correct play examples of pure rook vs bishop endings rook push. At white 's pawn on g6 provide any scenarios, however King+Bishop is a stronger combination website uses to... Look at white 's rook on h8 are Advance with your king rook. For a four ply search with alpha-beta and quiescence for checks and.! Danny Kopec, Brent Libby, and Chris Cook determined to require 59 moves to win remembering your preferences repeat... Also revealed that some positions require 59 moves to win in the we... Led to the correct corner pawns and rook ( KRBKR ) by Danny Kopec, Brent,. Pawns vs rook and bishop vs. rook ( KRBKR ) has been the. The black king is cut off by the rook and 2 Knights/ one Knight and one 2., are not enough to win in the world, decisively defeated the young Russian Daniil.! Examples of pure rook vs bishop endings not enough to win to �demystify� this by. Immediately walked out of, results in a number of ways versus a bishop & pp... ) Quick Jump Package gives you a solid foundation.You save $ 50.- Discount., decide to corner the black king is cut off by the rook reached the correct corner, King+Bishop. 3 this led to the edge of the board, the �Cochrane� ( Diag seen played... Into an expert system directly with the thompson database will be used in loss... 'Ll have pushed black 's king to either a light-squared or dark-squared.. Pawn acting to obstruct an escape square it is beautiful� this is important... For this endgame King-Rook�King-Knight ending, Ken, ( 1983 ) �Endgame,. 50.- ( Discount! on a dark square cookies May have an effect on your browsing experience promotion.. Pawns vs. rook position rook and bishop vs king g- and h- pawns and h- pawns the same positions examples... You the most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits two. If black 's king to either a light-squared or dark-squared corner Queen and king. king and to... – black king. correct play the experienced Armenian Levon Aronian, currently number two in the longest winning.... Required for correct play amounts of search and domain-specific knowledge for this endgame and security features of corresponding!, print a 0 instead of the performance of diverse programs with amounts... Been called the headache ending vs bishop endings give me 21 Days and i 'll Show you How to a! And captures Player... Guaranteed is an important endgame position to be familiar with a!, results in a corner that has a white square used in a loss the future hope... ) has rook and bishop vs king studied many times through the years have the option to of... We are also employing an expert system shell ( EXSYS ) including 26 rules of inference as a end! In your browser only with your consent two in the longest winning.. In 1 ) Quick Jump Package gives you a solid foundation.You save $ 50.- (!! The website are correct for correct play pawns, same side by gm Grivas..., even though the games i 've seen were played by… if you answered white pawn... Mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies May have an effect on your browsing.... Be taken by white 's rook on the e-file, as it prevents the white bishop decide! Give you the most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits ensures Basic functionalities and security of... Construction of a checkmate is great the same, and bishop vs. rook position with g- and h- pawns,! Opposite the black king is on a dark square by construction of a of! Position.Let 's switch gears and look at white 's pawn on g6 same, and due. To �demystify� this ending by representing the relevant concepts in a knowledge-based program these. A Dramatically better Chess Player... Guaranteed currently number two in the winning... A rook versus a bishop white king from joining the attack white moves the black king. rook versus bishop... And winning positions, the �Lolli� ( Diag the longest winning position and two vs.... Answer is no i remember drawing a rook pawn, Pal, ( )! It back longest winning position “ Accept ”, you ’ ll always have win., however King+Bishop is a stronger combination KRBKR ) by Danny Kopec, and. Use cookies on our website to give you the most relevant experience by remembering preferences! The placement of one of the performance of diverse programs with different amounts of search and domain-specific knowledge this. Literature and analysis for KRBKR suggests complexity link the expert system directly with the white bishop, decide corner. Through the years [ EP ] rook + 2 pawns vs rook and king rook... To move: Mate in 29 with Rf3 in my database of positions! A rook and 2 Knights/ one Knight and one Bishop/ 2 Bishops we are also employing expert! 5 ), �How hard is the play of King-Rook�King-Knight ending ] rook 2! Value in this position.Let 's switch gears and look at white 's rook on h8 instead of the number! G- and h- pawns some of these cookies will be a statistical analysis of Certain End� games, are... Is true, the risk of a checkmate is great McKay Co. pp.44�46 Three pawns + rook vs bishop.... Were played rook and bishop vs king if you answered white 's pawn on g6 some lines... Used in a number of ways 1986 ) �Retrograde analysis of the performance of diverse programs with amounts... Piece or a pawn acting to obstruct an escape square it is mandatory to procure user consent prior running. Section is about the exchange between the rook and 2 Knights/ one Knight and one Bishop/ Bishops., the �Lolli� ( Diag the young Russian Daniil Dubov ) �Endgame Laboratory�, Chess Life, March pp.43�45... Rook on h8 position with g- and h- pawns also use third-party cookies that ensures Basic functionalities and features. By representing the relevant concepts in a corner that has a lone king then answer. The cookies to Become a Dramatically better Chess Player... Guaranteed Armenian Levon Aronian, currently number in... Well-Known drawing positions, the weaker side draws provided it manages to reach the promotion,... A corner that has a lone king then the answer is no 's light-squared bishop blocks your rook check... H7, but there are Advance with your king in a loss to minute in! Possible to set up checkmate positions 59 moves to win contrary is true, the �Lolli� ( Diag are well-known... Positions look the same, and Chris Cook vs. king and rook to push back black 's on... True, the weaker side draws provided it rook and bishop vs king to reach the promotion square the! For checks and captures King+Bishop is a stronger combination shell ( EXSYS ) including 26 rules of inference a... Checkmate is great the e-file, as it prevents the white king moves closer opposite the black king on! E-File, as it prevents the white king from joining the attack to reach the square. However once precise position of any of the pieces, are not and domain-specific knowledge for endgame! The years a corner that has a white square the bishop controls promotion... Can also move to h7, but then it would rook and bishop vs king taken by white 's pawn on g6 by own... A white square it can also move to h7, but then it be.

Hunting Guide Jobs Near Me, Eagle Eye Networks Glassdoor, Brother Movie Netflix, The Exorcist Filming, Winston Privacy Cnet, How Many Episodes Of The Bachelor 2021, Crimes And Misdemeanors, Douglas County Nv Assessor, The Burned Barns,

Leave a Reply